The concept of bio-economy – Reflections on the theoretical background, goals, visions, and expectations

Project description

Bio-economy strives for a long-term conversion from fossil resources to an economy based on biogenic raw materials, waste, and renewable energies. According to the National Research Strategy "BioEconomy 2030" the term bio-economy covers agriculture as well as all productive sectors, including the related services which develop, produce, and process biological resources – such as plants, animals, and micro-organisms – or use them in any form. Bio-economy is seen as a tool to cope with global challenges, especially population growth, climate change, and the increasing demand for materials and energy. Partly the concept met with strong support, but partly also with considerable criticism, which is less directed to the objectives pursued, but rather to the strategies for their achievement. Such a fundamental transformation process which is associated with far-reaching changes to the prevailing production systems and product lines, affecting all societal sectors, would require a detailed analysis of the potential social, environmental, economic, and political consequences which has so far only partially been carried out. Furthermore, there are many interdependencies between ecosystems, biomass production, and the markets for food, energy, materials, and chemicals. These close interactions require an agreement on the theoretical background and the objectives of bio-economy and a prospective evaluation of the possible consequences of different utilization pathways.

Research on biomass has a long tradition at ITAS, dating back to the 1980s. The work covers a wide range of topics and issues, ranging from accompanying research to potential analyzes of agricultural and forestry resources and waste as well as algae in combination with different utilization pathways and processing technologies up to their evaluation in terms of sustainability. Furthermore, ITAS deals with opportunities and risks of emerging technologies such as genetic engineering and synthetic biology, to which an important role is attributed in the context of bio-economy (see literature).

Within the framework of the program-oriented research of the Helmholtz Association of German Research Centers, the emphasis should henceforth not only be on case studies in the field of bio-economy research but also on conceptual and theoretical work. Based on the above-mentioned criticism of the bio-economy strategy, the project deals with the genesis of the concept, the background, overarching goals and visions in various European and non-European countries. Gaps and weaknesses in the present national concept, for example in terms of the sustainability criteria used, the estimation of the available potentials, the participation of different social groups, or the implementation strategy pursued will be shown and alternatives will be discussed. The aim of this project is to undertake a critical reflection of the bio-based economy and to contribute to the theoretical substantiation of case studies by ITAS.

There are numerous intersections and synergy effects between this project and the accompanying research carried out by ITAS under the "bio-economy research program Baden-Württemberg" regarding the three pathways biogas, lignocellulose, and microalgae.

Publications


2020
Journal Articles
2018
Presentations
Priefer, C.; Meyer, R.
Rekonstruktion von Visionen und angestrebten Transformationspfaden in Diskurs und Politik zur Bioökonomie.
2018. 8. Internationale Konferenz des Netzwerks Technikfolgenabschätzung (NTA 2018), Karlsruhe, Germany, November 7–8, 2018 
Rösch, C.
Limitations and barriers of the concept of a circular bioeconomy.
2018. Projektmodul “Bioökonomie”, Universität Hohenheim (2018), Stuttgart, Germany, April 11, 2018 
2017
Book Chapters
Bräutigam, K.-R.
Biomasse aus der Abfallwirtschaft.
2017. Bioökonomie für Einsteiger. Hrsg.: J. Pietzsch, 54–65, Springer Spektrum 
Fritsche, U.; Rösch, C.
Die Bedingungen einer nachhaltigen Biokonomie.
2017. Bioökonomie für Einsteiger. Hrsg.: J. Pietzsch, 177–203, Springer Spektrum. doi:10.1007/978-3-662-53763-3_9
Grunwald, A.
Bioökonomie – Schlüssel zu unbegrenztem Wirtschafts- und Konsumwachstum?.
2017. Bioökonomie für Einsteiger. Hrsg.: J. Pietzsch, 205–211, Springer Spektrum 
Lippe, M.; Lewandowski, I.; Unseld, R.; Pucher, J.; Bräutigam, K.-R.
Die Herkunft der Biomasse.
2017. Bioökonomie für Einsteiger. Hrsg.: J. Pietzsch, 11–65, Springer Spektrum. doi:10.1007/978-3-662-53763-3_2
Presentations
Priefer, C.
Herausforderungen für die Umsetzung der Bioökonomie und Ansatzpunkte für die Weiterentwicklung der Konzepte.
2017. Bio statt Erdöl: Was ist Bioökonomie - und könnte sie die Welt retten? Podiumsgespräch, München, 7.Dezember 2017 
Priefer, C.
Shaping the bioeconomy: Key issues and major lines of conflict in the current discourse.
2017. 3rd European Technology Assessment Conference, Cork, IRL, May 17-19, 2017 
Priefer, C.; Böschen, S.; Meyer, R.; Kuppler, S.
Bioeconomy in the spotlight: TA-perspectives in a contested terain of transformation.
2017. 3rd European Technology Assessment Conference, Cork, IRL, May 17-19, 2017 
2015
Posters
Priefer, C.
Systems analysis on goals, visions, value chains and implementation steps of a bio-economy in Baden-Württemberg.
2015. Statusseminar des Forschungsprogramms Bioökonomie Baden-Württemberg, Stuttgart-Hohenheim, 29.Oktober 2015 
2012
Book Chapters
Meyer, R.
Grüne Gentechnik im Kontext landwirtschaftlicher Entwicklung - Reflexion gesellschaftlicher Kontroversen durch Technikfolgenabschätzung.
2012. Grüne Gentechnik : Zwischen Forschungsfreiheit und Anwendungsrisiko. Hrsg.: H. Grimm, 369–386, Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft 
Weiss, A.
Beiträge der Energieerzeugung mit Mikroalgen zu nachhaltiger Energieversorgung und -nutzung?.
2012. Der Systemblick auf Innovation : Technikfolgenabschätzung in der Technikgestaltung. Hrsg.: M. Decker, 451–454, edition sigma 
Conference Papers
Knapp, M.
Laiendiskurse über Grüne Gentechnik. Wahrnehmung und Perspektiven.
2012. Grüne Gentechnik : Zwischen Forschungsfreiheit und Anwendungsrisiko. Ed.: H. Grimm, 175–193, Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft 
2011
Journal Articles
Grunwald, A.
Synthetische Biologie. Verantwortungszuschreibung und Demokratie.
2011. Information Philosophie, 2011 (5), 8–18 
2010
Journal Articles
Jörissen, J.; Schippl, J.; Weinberger, N.
Strategien und Technologien zur Erhöhung der Rohstoffproduktivität.
2010. Chemie Ingenieur Technik, 82, 1903–12. doi:10.1002/cite.201000113
Kappler, G.; Koch, B.; Leible, L.
Wald-Energieholzaufkommen in Baden-Württemberg. Bereitstellungskosten und Standortanalyse.
2010. Allgemeine Forst- und Jagdzeitung, 181, 117–22 
Reports/Preprints
Meyer, R.; Rösch, C.; Sauter, A.
Opportunities and challenges facing new energy crops. Summary.
2010. Büro für Technikfolgen-Abschätzung beim Deutschen Bundestag (TAB) 
2009
Journal Articles
Leible, L.; Kälber, S.; Kappler, G.
Biomass-to-liquid: Hoffnungsträger für eine umweltfreundliche mobile Zukunft?.
2009. DVGW Energie / Wasser-Praxis, 60 (4), 17–19 
Reports/Preprints
Bütschi, D.; Gram, S.; Haugen, J. M.; Meyer, R.; Sauter, A.; Steyaert, S.; Torgersen, H.
Genetically modified plants and foods: Challenges and future issues in Europe - Final Report.
2009. EPTA 

Contact

Dipl.-Ing. Juliane Jörissen
Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT)
Institute for Technology Assessment and Systems Analysis (ITAS)
P.O. Box 3640
76021 Karlsruhe
Germany